What Our Guests Are Saying

“This was my very first time at a cigar lounge, and I'm so glad I chose this place for that special moment. What an incredible experience! The atmosphere is absolutely unmatched — elegant, relaxing, and perfect for enjoying a great cigar.”

“Had a great time at the Tasting Room. Drinks were good on point and the cigar selection were most of the brands I go for. Very clean nice atmosphere and the owner was very welcoming. I will visit the place whenever I am in the Madison Wisconsin area.”

“What a place! The humidor is HUGE and has so many choices. The staff were amazing, super helpful and friendly... Don't get me started on the Honey Badger! If you like cigars, hit this place up.”

“VERY welcome addition to Waunakee. Fantastic cocktails. The staff knows what they are talking about. Cigar selection is fantastic. They can pair your cigar with a perfect cocktail.”

“Had a great time at the grand opening! Tasting Room has a great atmosphere and is a perfect spot to sit back, enjoy a drink, and have a good cigar. Really enjoyed my time here and I'm looking forward to coming back and seeing this place grow!”

“Absolutely stunning atmosphere. The leather seating is so comfortable and the humidor selection is incredible. The staff paired a cigar with a bourbon cocktail that was pure perfection. Can't wait to come back!”

“The patio with the fire pits is my new favorite spot in Madison. Cozy, elegant, and the drinks are crafted with real care. A true hidden gem for anyone who appreciates a good cigar and a great cocktail.”

“What a beautiful lounge! Sophisticated without being stuffy. The craft cocktails are some of the best I've had in the area, and the cigar selection is top notch. The ambiance is simply unmatched.”

“I've been to cigar lounges all over the country and Tasting Room holds its own with the best of them. Expert staff, incredible selection, and the atmosphere is warm and welcoming. Five stars all the way.”

“From the moment you walk in, you feel like family. The owners are passionate about what they do and it shows in every detail. The pairing class was an unforgettable experience. Highly recommend!”

“Hands down the finest cigar and spirit destination in Dane County. The ventilation is fantastic, seats are plush, and the staff's recommendation on scotch pairing was spot on.”

“Came in for ladies' cocktail night and was blown away. Sophisticated atmosphere, super friendly bartenders, and an amazing outdoor heated patio!”

“The walk-in humidor is a cigar lover's dream. Spanish cedar, perfect humidity, and brands I can't find anywhere else in Madison. The staff actually knows their stuff and helped me find a new favorite.”

“Celebrated my husband's birthday here and it could not have been more perfect. The ambiance, the service, the cocktails — everything was five stars. They made us feel like VIPs the entire evening.”

“As someone who travels for work and visits lounges across the country, this place is genuinely special. The ventilation is top-tier, the seating is luxurious, and the bourbon selection rivals any big-city lounge.”

“Even if you're not a cigar person, come for the cocktails. The bartenders are true mixologists — every drink is a work of art. The Old Fashioned here is the best I've had in Wisconsin, hands down.”

“The outdoor patio with the fire pits is unreal on a cool evening. Grabbed a cigar, a whiskey, and sat by the fire with friends. Felt like a private club but welcoming to everyone. Already planning my next visit.”

“Such a classy spot for a date night. Dim lighting, leather chairs, great music at the perfect volume. We shared a charcuterie board and a couple of cocktails while enjoying a cigar. Pure relaxation.”

“The pairing class was worth every penny. Learned how to match cigars with different spirits and walked away with knowledge I'll use forever. The instructor was passionate and made it genuinely fun.”

“I was nervous coming in as a first-timer to cigars, but the staff made me feel so comfortable. They walked me through everything, recommended a mild stick, and paired it with a cocktail. I'm hooked now!”

“Member humidor locker program is fantastic. My sticks are kept in perfect condition and I always have a seat waiting. This is the kind of place you become a regular at on your very first visit.”

“Came for a comedy night and stayed for the whole experience. Great drinks, great laughs, and the cigar selection is impressive. Tasting Room really knows how to put on an event. Already bought tickets for the next one.”

“The attention to detail here is remarkable — from the glassware to the ice to the garnish, everything is intentional. You can tell the owners genuinely care about delivering an elevated experience. Bravo.”

“The heated patio is a game-changer for Wisconsin winters. Sat outside in comfort with a cigar and a hot cocktail while the heaters kept us warm. Such a thoughtful touch that most places don't bother with.”

“Best cigar lounge I've been to in the Midwest, period. The humidor is immaculate, the staff is knowledgeable without being pretentious, and the cocktail program is genuinely craft. A must-visit if you're anywhere near Madison.”

“Booked the private space for a corporate gathering and it exceeded every expectation. Elegant, comfortable, and the team handled everything flawlessly. Our clients are still talking about it. Thank you, Tasting Room!”

“The whiskey selection alone is worth the trip. Rare bottles I've only read about, displayed beautifully behind the bar. The pour I had was generous and the bartender's recommendation was spot on. This place gets it right.”

“What a gem for Waunakee! Walked in not knowing what to expect and left already planning a return trip. The vibe is upscale but unpretentious, the drinks are creative, and the cigar selection is extensive. Love this place.”

“I've been smoking cigars for 30 years and I'm picky about where I go. Tasting Room checks every box — climate-controlled humidor, comfortable seating, excellent ventilation, and staff who treat you like family. Five stars.”

“Girls' night out and we had the best time! The bartenders made us feel so welcome, the cocktails were gorgeous and delicious, and the whole atmosphere was just chic. We're making this our regular spot.”

“The leather club chairs are the most comfortable seating I've found in any lounge. Sink in, light up a cigar, sip a craft cocktail, and watch the game on the big screen. It's my happy place. Highly recommend.”

“From the moment we walked in, the hospitality was unmatched. The owner came over to chat and made us feel right at home. The cigar and cocktail pairing was inspired. This is what a lounge should feel like.”

“The craft cocktail menu rotates and every new addition I've tried has been excellent. The bartenders clearly take pride in their work. Paired with a Padron and a leather chair by the window — perfection.”

“My partner surprised me with a date night here and it was magical. The lighting, the music, the smell of fine tobacco — it's an experience, not just a bar. We felt transported. Already booked our next visit.”

“I've been a cigar smoker for decades and I'm very particular about humidity and storage. Their humidor is dialed in perfectly. Every stick I've pulled has been in pristine condition. That tells you everything about how they run this place.”

“Tasting Room has become our go-to for celebrating special occasions. The staff remembers us, the drinks are consistently incredible, and the atmosphere never disappoints. It feels like our own private club.”

“The Old Fashioned here is the gold standard. Made the Wisconsin way with brandy and real care. Paired it with a Romeo y Julieta on the patio and had one of the best afternoons I've had in years. This place is a treasure.”

“Booked a private cigar rolling event for my husband's 40th and it was beyond anything I imagined. The roller was so talented and engaging, and the staff made sure every guest was taken care of. Worth every penny.”

“I work nearby and come in for lunch occasionally. The humidor is always immaculate, the staff greets you by name, and the coffee they serve is excellent. A true daytime refuge for a quick cigar and a great pour.”

“The whiskey wall is a sight to behold. I'm a bourbon enthusiast and I found bottles I've been hunting for years. The bartender walked me through a flight and I left with a new favorite. Already told all my friends.”

“Came in skeptical — I'm not a cigar smoker — but the staff made me feel completely at ease. They recommended a mild, flavored cigar and a sweet cocktail that I genuinely loved. I'm already planning to bring my wife back.”

“The Waunakee location has the best vibe of any lounge I've visited in Wisconsin. It's cozy, the music is always perfect, and the outdoor fire pit area is magical in the evening. A true community gem.”

“I've been a member of the humidor locker program for six months now and it's the best investment I've made. My cigars are perfectly maintained, I always have a reserved seat, and the staff treats me like royalty.”

“The cocktail menu is genuinely creative — not just the same old standards. I tried three different drinks and each was beautifully balanced and presented. The smoked Old Fashioned is an absolute must-try.”

“The ventilation system here is incredible. I've been to lounges where you leave reeking of smoke — not here. The air is clean, comfortable, and the temperature is perfect. They clearly invested in doing it right.”

“Celebrated my promotion here with friends and it was perfect. The private alcove gave us intimacy without feeling isolated. The staff anticipated every need before we even asked. An unforgettable evening.”

“The cigar selection rivals any shop in Chicago or Minneapolis. Rare OpusX, Davidoff, Padron — they have it all and the staff knows every blend inside and out. I drove an hour and it was worth every minute.”

“The pairing class was an absolute highlight of my year. The instructor was so knowledgeable and passionate, and I left feeling like I actually understood how to match cigars with spirits. Can't recommend it enough.”

“The leather club chairs are the most comfortable I've ever sat in. I sank in, ordered a Manhattan and a Padron 1964, and lost track of two hours. This is what a cigar lounge should feel like. Pure class.”

“The heated outdoor patio is a Wisconsin game-changer. Sat outside in November with a cigar and a hot toddy, perfectly comfortable by the fire pit. Most places shut their patios down — Tasting Room makes it work year-round.”

“The scotch selection is genuinely world-class. I found a 25-year single malt I'd been searching for everywhere. The pour was generous, the glassware was proper, and the bartender knew the tasting notes cold. Exceptional.”

“Girls' night at Tasting Room is the best in town. The cocktails are gorgeous, the atmosphere is chic without being pretentious, and the staff makes you feel like a VIP. We're making it a monthly tradition.”

“I've been smoking cigars for 25 years and I'm extremely particular about humidor conditions. Tasting Room's humidor is dialed in to perfection — every single stick I've pulled has been in flawless condition. That's rare.”

“The comedy night was fantastic — intimate setting, great comedians, and the drinks kept flowing. Tasting Room knows how to put on an event. We laughed all night and already bought tickets for the next showcase.”

“The attention to detail is what sets this place apart. Hand-cut ice, proper glassware, fresh garnishes, and cigars stored at perfect humidity. You can tell the owners are passionate about every single element. Bravo.”

“I came in as a complete beginner and the staff was so patient and welcoming. They walked me through the whole humidor, helped me pick a mild cigar, and suggested a cocktail pairing. I left feeling like a regular. I'm hooked.”

“The private event space is stunning. We hosted a client appreciation night and the team handled everything flawlessly — from cigar selections to a custom cocktail menu. Our clients are still raving about it weeks later.”

“Date night here is pure magic. The dim lighting, the leather seating, the smell of fine tobacco — it transports you. We shared a charcuterie board, sipped craft cocktails, and enjoyed a cigar together. Already booked our next visit.”

“The craft cocktail program rotates seasonally and every new addition I've tried has been outstanding. The bartenders are true mixologists who clearly take pride in their craft. Paired with a great cigar, it's perfection.”

“Tasting Room has become our go-to spot for celebrating special occasions. The staff remembers us by name, the drinks are consistently incredible, and the atmosphere never disappoints. It feels like our own private club.”